Many animal lovers and pet owners adore the German Shepherd for its loveable yet robust nature. They are popular for their skill and wit, but some people believe that this dog breed can be dangerous in some cases. So, can German Shepherds kill?
German Shepherds can kill if they have the motive for it, and their inherent agility, speed, strength, and intelligence support this capacity. However, their genetic nature suits guarding, herding, assistive, and protective purposes, making them less likely to kill intentionally.
In this article, we’ll explore different scenarios and answer your desire to know whether German Shepherds can kill, whether that be another human, other dogs, or various animals.
While the breed’s traits can give insight into many of the below scenarios, every dog is unique and would handle confrontations differently. Training from a young age dramatically influences their aggression, behavior, and where they will draw the line.
Stick around to find out about the German Shepherd’s capacity for fighting and killing in various contexts and situations.
Could a German Shepherd Kill a Human?
Deaths from dog attacks are pretty rare, but they can happen. In a 27 year period between 1979-2005, there was an average of 19 human fatalities by dogs in the US. Some breeds are known to kill a human more than others, but does this include the German Shepherd?
A German Shepherd could kill a human and has been known to kill in some situations. They have a strong bite force capable of crushing human bones and large sharp canines that can easily cut into human arteries. They also have quicker reflexes and superior fighting instincts to most humans.
More recent data from the 15-year period between 2005-2019 evidenced that dogs killed 521 Americans, an increased average of 34 a year. However, this could be due to the general increase in the canine population. Pit Bulls were responsible for 66% (346) of these deaths. Combined, Pit Bulls and Rottweilers caused 76% of the total fatalities.
There is proof that owners of dangerous dogs are much more likely to be convicted of violent crimes, which could explain the Pit Bull’s disproportionate rate of fatal attacks.
The latest statistics from Dogsbite.org reveal 48 US deaths were caused by dogs in 2019. From these, 2 were caused by the German Shepherd breed.
One case involved an 11-year old German Shepherd mix that killed an 8-month old child while her mother slept. She was found intoxicated at the scene and was subsequently charged with felony child abuse. The second case involved the death of an 88-year old female who was 6 German Shepherds mauled.
Given the variety of circumstances surrounding various attacks, research into lethal encounters between canines and humans has proved extremely controversial.
There are many likely factors involved in fatal dog attacks, such as the dogs’ size, number, and nutritional status; the dogs’ previous violent interactions with people; the victim’s age, size, health, and behavior; and the lack of other humans in the area.
Some working German Shepherds are trained in aggression, such as police, protection, and military dogs. As a former police officer, I’ve witnessed dogs trained to attack on many occasions, showing their hostility. Let’s just say I know which side of the law I’d rather be on! But ultimately, these clever dogs are trained to hold or subdue their target on command.
If you want to know who would win a fight between a German Shepherd and a human, check out this article, Are German Shepherds Stronger Than Humans?
Can a German Shepherd Kill a Rottweiler?
German Shepherds are incredibly protective over their loved ones, and they may push themselves to the limit to defend their caregivers. The degree to which they fight and harm the Rottweiler will depend on the situation’s context and the fight’s motive. So, can a German Shepherd kill a Rottweiler?
A German Shepherd may kill a Rottweiler as a last resort if it is the only way to defend its loved ones. But, trained dogs usually draw the line before death is imminent, and a German Shepherd would suffer severe injuries due to the Rottweiler’s powerful bite.
Even though Rottweilers exhibit more aggression to strangers and German Shepherds are typically aloof with strangers than aggressive, German Shepherds still pack a punch. GSDs are generally friendly towards other dogs unless they are defending their family or territory.
Still, when comparing physical attributes, German Shepherds are more agile and faster than Rottweilers. But Rottweilers have a powerful force behind their bite, which would leave a German Shepherd severely injured. Depending on the training and traits of each unique dog, a GSD may not survive either.
While it is technically possible for a German Shepherd to kill a Rottweiler, the odds of this happening are rather slim. They are loveable and empathetic, and their temperament would likely prevent them from intentionally killing another dog. German Shepherds may draw the line after the Rottweiler has been defeated or has sustained injuries making it incapable of continuing the fight or endangering loved ones.
Who Will Win in a Fight Between a Rottweiler and a German Shepherd?
Can a German Shepherd Kill a Deer?
German Shepherds were initially bred for herding, guarding livestock, and protecting others from wild animals such as wolves and coyotes. They were not bred for hunting but commonly accompanied and assisted hunters on trips. So, can a German Shepherd kill a deer?
If a German Shepherd is trained in hunting from a young age, its speed, agility, strength, and wit can allow it to kill a baby deer. German Shepherds typically cannot kill a mature deer, and deer may kill dogs in some situations, such as an aggressive buck or a defensive doe caring for her young.
Still, whether or not a German Shepherd could kill a deer will depend on the unique dog. Most are not adept with hunting, but many display prey and hunter’s instincts from a very young age, making some potentially suitable for hunting dogs. Training that involves luring and tracking can encourage hunting skills.
The breed has inherent traits which make them great hunting companions, such as their obedience, soft mouths suitable for carrying prey to their owners, and their sharp hearing skills suitable for noting movement. These traits are directly in line with their original breeding purposes, making them more likely to act as pointer dogs, retrievers, flushers, and assistants than hunting and killing the deer themselves.
It’s always recommended to work as a team if your German Shepherd is a trained hunter, as letting them hunt solo is dangerous for them, regardless of their wit and skill. Contrary to popular belief, this docile and graceful creature can be incredibly dangerous.
Although deer commonly flee at the sight of a predator, some cases can be fatal for dogs. Aggressive bucks and defensive doe caring for their young may attack and kill a German Shepherd.
Can a German Shepherd Kill a Snake?
Although German Shepherds are less likely to attack and intentionally kill larger animals or dogs, there is a gray area concerning smaller animals and reptiles. Still, facing a snake may be harmless or deadly for a dog, depending on the snake. So, can a German Shepherd kill a snake?
German Shepherds can kill a snake if it’s seen as a threat to loved ones, especially if the dog has strong hunting instincts. Occasionally, they may unintentionally kill a snake by playing with them. However, they generally leave harmless and small snakes alone or inform owners of their presence.
How a German Shepherd would handle a snake’s encounter will strongly depend on training, the snake, and its context. Since they pride themselves on their ability to protect and guard their owners, the dog’s behavior will rely on the best way to ensure their safety in such cases.
German Shepherds generally do not kill snakes unless they feel there is a solid reason for it. Owners who have harmless garden snakes have noted that their dogs become curious by sniffing and watching them but generally leave them alone once no threat is detected.
Some dogs choose to note the snake’s location and inform their owner of its presence, after which the owner would take action accordingly. Even a few are freaked out by snakes and run away from them, while many German Shepherds may unintentionally kill a small snake while playing with it.
However, the few dogs who have inherent hunter’s instincts or are trained in hunting from a young age may choose small snakes and reptiles for target practice. They can chase snakes around, track them, and kill them within seconds once they get their paws on them. If it’s noticed that the snake is a threat or is plotting against their humans by hiding under cars ready to strike, the dog may kill it as soon as possible.
While the German Shepherd breed can kill, this is only carried out in scarce situations. They are people-oriented, loving, and obedient to their owners. They will do anything to protect them. Always make sure your dog is trained from a young age to channel their instincts and protect them from harmful situations.
Related Posts You May Like:
- PubMed: Human fatalities resulting from dog attacks in the United States, 1979-2005
- DogsBite.org: 2019 dog bite fatality statistics
- DogsBite.org: Tucson Mother Arrested After Infant Found Dead with Dog Bite Injuries
- Lexington Herald-Leader: Tennessee woman mauled to death by six German Shepherds
- PubMed: Ownership of high-risk (“vicious”) dogs as a marker for deviant behaviors: implications for risk assessment
- Inside Dogs World: Dog Bite Explained – Top 20 Dogs With The Strongest Bite Force